Plagiarism and free speech

The
International Campaign for Real History

[images and captions added by this website]

Chicago, August 28, 2007

Course cancelled a week before class

DePaul pulls plug on controversial professor

By Ron
Grossman Tribune staff reporter

THE required reading was at the bookstore, the students had the course syllabus, and space in Political Science 235, “Equality in
Social Justice,” was standing-room only when DePaul
University pulled the plug Friday on what was to have been Norman
Finkelstein’s final year at the school.

A controversial scholar — accused by critics of fomenting anti-Semitism and lauded by supporters as a forthright critic of Israel — Finkelstein attracted wide attention across the academic world when he was denied tenure in the spring.

By Monday, the books for his course had been pulled from the DePaul bookstore’s shelves, while his case was restarting a firestorm of protest. The
American Association of University Professors was preparing a letter to the university, protesting
Finkelstein’s treatment as a serious violation of academic ethics.

Finkelstein vowed not to take the rebuff lying down — or, perhaps more correctly, to do something just like that. In addition to canceling his course, the university informed him that his office was no longer his.

“I intend to go to my
office on the first day of classes and, if my
way is barred, to engage in civil disobedience,”
Finkelstein, 53, said in a telephone interview.
“If arrested, I’ll go on a hunger strike. If
released, I’ll do it all over again. I’ll fast
in jail for as long as it takes.”

Fall classes start Sept. 5 at DePaul, where
Finkelstein has been a faculty member for six years. During that time, his star has risen and fallen at the Catholic school, founded by the
Vincentian order.

His books brought him far-reaching renown. They also were condemned for their provocative language, as in the “The Holocaust Industry,” where he called efforts to get compensation from Germany for World
War II slave laborers a “shakedown.” Finkelstein, himself Jewish, has described leaders of
American-Jewish organizations as
“Holocaust-mongers.”

He has engaged in a long-running feud with
Harvard University law professor Alan
Dershowitz, a strong supporter of Israel. He has charged Dershowitz with appropriating other scholars’ findings
[i.e. plagiarism]; Dershowitz was similarly skeptical of the legitimacy of
Finkelstein’s work when asked by DePaul to comment on his application for tenure, the academic equivalent of a lifetime job guarantee.

Nonetheless, Finkelstein’s work has been praised by ivory-tower luminaries such as the distinguished linguist Noam Chomsky and the late Raul
Hilberg, dean of Holocaust historians.
Finkelstein’s supporters are planning a lecture-rally for him in October in Chicago.

Two years ago, Finkelstein was held up as an example of DePaul’s commitment to freedom of inquiry by its president, Dennis
Holtschneider.

Students have held Finkelstein in high regard, reporting that his tone in the classroom is measured, quite unlike the red-hot rhetoric of his books.

This year, though, Dean Chuck Suchar
found Finkelstein’s scholarship inconsistent with
“DePaul’s Vincentian values,” among them respect for others’ views. Holtschneider seconded that motion in refusing Finkelstein’s tenure.

Student
support continues

DePaul officials declined to comment on the case. Denise Mattson, associate vice president for public affairs, said: “Finkelstein has been assigned to an administrative leave with full pay and benefits for the 2007-08 academic year. Administrative leave relieves professors from their teaching responsibilities. He was informed of the reasons that precipitated this leave last spring.”

He was denied tenure in June, but officials could offer no explanation for why his courses were left in the schedule.

On Friday, Andrew Riplinger, a DePaul student registered for Finkelstein’s course, received an e-mail from him.

“Professor Finkelstein wrote that if the course was canceled by the university, it would be taught at another location,” said Riplinger. “Then the university sent an e-mail announcing the course had been canceled.”

Riplinger and other student supporters, fearing such an action, have been meeting regularly over the summer and communicating their uneasiness to the administration. Their committee was scheduled to meet Monday evening in the DePaul student center, Riplinger said.

Final year
at school threatened

According to the norms of academia, a professor denied tenure has the right to a final year of teaching at the university that turns him down. The watchdog of those rights is the American
Association of University Professors, the umbrella organization of college teachers, which can censure a school found in violation of its ground rules.
Such a finding also can be the preliminary to a lawsuit against the university by the faculty member.

According to Jonathan Knight, director of the AAUP’s program in academic freedom and tenure, a university owes a faculty member denied tenure more than just a year’s salary. He or she has the right to a classroom (and presumably an office). A university can’t simply buy him or her out by invoking administrative leave, Knight said.

He added that a faculty member can’t be put on administrative leave without a hearing except in an extreme emergency.

“We’re not aware of an emergency requiring
DePaul to take such action at the 11th hour and
59th minute,” Knight said.

Finkelstein said that, rather than filing a lawsuit, he intends to fight the university’s action with a hunger strike, and the attendant publicity.

“In the court of public opinion, I can win,”
Finkelstein said. “I say: ‘Let the people judge.'”

Copyright © 2007,
Chicago Tribune

ALAN
DERSHOWITZ, the outspoken Harvard Law School professor, is in the middle of a nasty Jewish squabble with Norman Finkelstein, who accused him of plagiarism

DePAUL
University [Chicago] canceled the one remaining class taught by a controversial professor who has accused some Jews of improperly using the legacy of the Holocaust.

Norman Finkelstein, whose work led to a long-running public feud with Harvard law professor
Alan Dershowitz, says he may respond by committing civil disobedience when classes resume Sept. 5.

Finkelstein, 53, was denied tenure in June after six years on the DePaul faculty, but he was permitted to teach for the one year remaining on his contract.

On Friday, however, the university e-mailed students saying that Finkelstein’s sole political science course had been canceled. By Monday, the books for the course had been pulled from the
DePaul bookstore’s shelves.

Finkelstein’s most recent book, “Beyond
Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the
Abuse of History,” is largely an attack on
Dershowitz’s “The Case for Israel.” In it,
Finkelstein argues that Israel uses the outcry over perceived anti-Semitism as a weapon to stifle criticism.

Dershowitz, who threatened to sue Finkelstein’s publisher for libel, urged DePaul officials to reject Finkelstein’s tenure bid in June.

The American Association of University
Professors is preparing a letter to the university protesting Finkelstein’s treatment as a serious violation of academic ethics, the Chicago Tribune reported Tuesday.

Finkelstein told the newspaper that he planned to wage his own campaign against the administration.

“I intend to go to my office on the first day of classes and, if my way is barred, to engage in civil disobedience,” Finkelstein said. “If arrested, I’ll go on a hunger strike. If released,
I’ll do it all over again. I’ll fast in jail for as long as it takes.”

After he was denied tenure, Finkelstein, a son of Holocaust survivors, posted a letter on his Web site explaining the school officials’ reasons, including Finkelstein’s “deliberately hurtful” scholarship along, lack of involvement with the school and tendency for public clashes with other scholars.

“In the opinion of those opposing tenure, your unprofessional personal attacks divert the conversation away from consideration of ideas, and polarize and simplify conversations that deserve layered and subtle consideration,” school President
Dennis Holtschneider wrote in a letter dated June
8. DePaul at the time verified the letter was authentic.

Denise Mattson, the university’s associate vice president for public affairs, released a statement saying Finkelstein was on administrative leave with full pay for the academic year.

“Administrative leave relieves professors from their teaching responsibilities. He was informed of the reasons that precipitated this leave last spring,” the statement said.

Norman
Finkelstein accuses Alan Dershowitz of
plagiarism | continued

Gordon Thomas
calls Dershowitz a Plagiarist and
Fraudster

Finkelstein interviewed
by Beirut newspaper after his university sacks
him

Finkelstein
interviewed by Counterpunch after his university
sacks him

Jun 10, 2007: Controversial
DePaul Professor Denied Tenure

Aug 23, 2007:

Finkelstein’s
eulogy on death of the Real Historian, Prof Raul
Hilberg

Our website dossier on
Finkelstein and his crusade

Norman Finkelstein’s website is www.normanfinkelstein.com

Use our website’s excellent search engine to read more on the sleazy lawyer Alan Dershowitz:
“search”
> “Dershowitz” (44 items)

The
above item is reproduced without editing other than
typographical

Register your name and address
to go on the Mailing List to receive

or to hear when and where he will next speak near you

©
Focal Point
2005 write to David
Irving