death of a historian

LONDON — Historian
Hugh Trevor-Roper, who investigated
“The Last Days of Hitler” in his most famous book but sullied his own reputation by incorrectly authenticating
diaries said to have been the tyrant’s, died
Sunday at the age of 89.

Trevor-Roper, who received the title
Lord Dacre of Glanton in 1979, had been ill with cancer and died at Sobell House, a hospice in Oxford, his family announced.

He gained steadily in stature throughout his career and was Oxford
University’s Regius Professor of Modern
History for 13 years before becoming master of the Cambridge college,
Peterhouse.

“He is the most eloquent, sophisticated and assured historian of our age, and has never written an inelegant sentence or produced an incoherent argument,” critic and fellow academic Noel Annan said of him.

It was his 1947 examination of Adolf
Hitler’s demise, commissioned by the
British government, that brought him the widest renown.

During World War II he had served in
British intelligence, and he was selected by the government to establish precisely what had happened to Hitler at the end of his life in an underground Berlin bunker.
The book was described by The
Observer newspaper as “a masterpiece of narrative and of historical detective work.”

It was
Trevor-Roper’s stature as a Hitler
expert that led to his embarrassment
over the “Hitler Diaries” hoax in
1983.

On his authentication, The Sunday
Times agreed to pay the German magazine Stern for serialization rights to diaries supposedly written in
Hitler’s own hand. The German government revealed they were forgeries before the
London newspaper began publication, and its money was returned.

Trevor-Roper said Stern had assured him that all tests for authenticity, including those by three handwriting experts, were positive.

The historian made a public apology and explained that he had seen the diaries
“for a few hours only” under supervision, and was impressed by the bulk of the material — 60 volumes, in light of confirmation of the physical tests.

A Stern reporter and the
confessed forger of the diaries were each sentenced to more than four years in prison.

Trevor-Roper was ridiculed in the press, perhaps more than he would have been had he not had a reputation for confrontation. He had public feuds with writer Evelyn Waugh and historian
Arnold Toynbee.

Waugh, who had argued with him over religion, later wrote that Trevor-Roper’s appointment to the Regius history chair
“showed malice to the church.”

Trevor-Roper “has never suffered fools gladly, never tempered intellectual disdain with feigned civility, never pulled his literary punches,” The
Observer wrote in 1982. It quoted his longtime friend, the philospher A.J.
Ayer, as saying of the young
Trevor-Roper, “Some might think him lacking in charity.”

A.L. Rowse, the eminent historian of the Elizabethan period and himself a famously prickly academic, described Trevor-Roper “our most riveting historical essayist.”

He went on in a less flattering vein:
“Brightness, briskness illuminate the pages, but there are no shadows, no subtlety, not much perception of character, no pathos or insight into the soul or human suffering. Plenty of wit and cynical observations; no sense of the tragedy — or the poetry — of history.”

Born Jan. 15, 1914 in Glanton, northern
England, the son of a doctor, Hugh Redwald
Trevor-Roper earned a double first-class degree at Christ Church College,
Oxford.

He made an impressive debut as a historian in 1940 with publication of a biography of Archbishop Laud, the powerful 17th century Archbishop of
Canterbury who suppressed Calvinism and
Puritanism.

After the war he returned to Oxford as a fellow of Christ Church college until
1957, and fellow of Oriel College from
1957 to 1980.

On retirement from the Regius professorship he moved to the University of Cambridge where he was master of
Peterhouse until 1987. While there he made headlines with a struggle to remove a college fellow with whom he had a personal conflict.

In 1954 he married Lady Alexandra
Howard-Johnstone. They had no children, but Lady Alexandra, who died in
1997, had a son and daughter from a previous marriage. Trevor-Roper is survived by his three step-children.

Copyright ©
2003, The Associated Press

Radical’s Diary [and Radical’s
Diary flashback]