Attempts by the traditional enemies of the truth to prevent David Irving speaking in New Zealand, September 2004 | ||||||||
click
image for high-resolution The
2004 Ban on David Irving's visit to NZ: Blunt
Answers to some Frequently Asked Questions
Summary: In February 2004 David Irving
began planning a visit to the USA and New
Zealand. On May 22 he ordered and paid for the
ticket, with Qantas flying the segment from Los
Angeles to Auckland. On May 23 the New Zealand
government placed his name on a banned list
circulated to airlines. On July 21 the NZ
Herald reported that the Jewish community
was demanding a ban on his entry. On July 22
Immigration stated that a final decision on his
September visit had not been made. On July 31
Prime Minister Helen Clark said that Mr Irving's
views should not bar him from the country. On
September 15 the NZ Labour Ministry warned all
airlines to comply strictly with immigration law
regarding carrying banned passengers. On September 16 Mr Irving was denied
boarding of the Qantas flight at Los Angeles, on
direct instructions from the NZ Immigration
Service. [Photos]
The country's press strongly disapproved this
action. He applied
on October 18, 2004 for the special permit which
the prime minister indicated he would require;
but she made
plain a few days later that she would not
allow it anyway. DAVID
IRVING was to travel to New Zealand in
mid-September 2004 to speak to the country's
National Press Club which had extended an
invitation to him to address a public meeting in
Wellington. He would also research in the
country's national archives for volume 3 of his
nearly-completed Churchill biography, which is
to appear in 2005 ("Churchills War", vol.
iii: "The Sundered Dream"). The usual bigots demanded
that his visit be stopped. At first Prime
Minister Helen Clark saw
no reason to comply. He had visited New Zealand twice before, in
1986 and 1987, promoting his pioneering work on
the Hungarian Uprising of 1956, and "Churchill's
War", vol. i: "Struggle for Power". He had no
criminal record in NZ or elsewhere -- a clean
driving licence for 50 years -- and there were
no known legal reasons to prevent his entry. The fact of his tour had been announced on
this website since 2003. He had invited his many
friends in Australia to fly in to join him. On
July 17, 2004 however the local Jewish Council
confidently announced
that it would prevent him speaking. Council
chairman David Zwartz (Israeli consul in
Auckland) led the clamour. His community was
still suffering from the stinging rebuke
delivered to Israel by the prime minister after
a spy and fake passports scandal; one of his own
council members turned out to be the third man
sought by police in the scandal, after he had
fled with his family to sanctuary in Israel. The whole gang joined in. From Los Angeles
the Simon Wiesenthal Center wrote a
secret letter to the New Zealand ambassador
demanding that Mr Irving be excluded from New
Zealand, and wrongly claiming that he had
criminal convictions for incitement. Two
well-timed attacks on Jewish cemeteries in
Wellington further distracted public and
government attention; since speculation was rife
about the perpetrators, and Zwartz's council
only talked about putting up a reward, Mr
Irving offered a ten thousand dollar reward
(guaranteed by a wealthy California
supporter). THIS uproar was no more than expected. Each
such local organisation acts on orders from a
sinister central organisation, the oddly-named
Anti-Defamation
League of the Bnai Brith, based in New
York. You wonder how your local NZ journalists
and politicians are suddenly so well informed?
The ADL ships out packages of prepared press
briefings, circulars, and smear material (as
Noam Chomsky, Auberon Waugh, and other well
known authors describe in their memoirs). The
ADL has an annual budget of over US $60m for its
unsavoury task. Its long-time director is
Abraham Foxman, left, a corrupt
official who solicits bribes from criminals
wanted by the US Federal authorities and who has
made it his personal ambition to destroy Mr
Irving, regardless of the obloquy that results
against his fellows around the world. A
respected Rabbi recently called Foxman their own
"worst
enemy". The ADL does not hesitate to libel people as
anti-Semites. In 2003 it had to pay
damages of US $10m to a Denver, Colorado,
couple. Where it can get away with it, ADL
front-organisations fund violent thugs to
photograph, intimidate, or break up
audiences. The ADL has been fighting a secret battle to
silence David Irving since at
least 1977. Hiding behind a campaign
ostensibly directed against racism, Foxman and
the ADL try to suppress Real History and free
speech worldwide. The ADL's own chosen motif is
the Snake and Star of David (below). They exert great influence in Australia,
where the local body bribed
the political parties of both John Howard and
his predecessor Paul Keating. Billonaire
Isi Leibler, right, who headed the body at that
time, is now chairman of the World Jewish
Congress; he admitted
that he was behind the campaign against Mr
Irving. Canberra has refused Mr Irving a new
entry visa ever since 1992. He had toured
Australia in 1986 and 1987 without problem, and
had seen his Churchill biography shoot to No. 1
on the Sydney Morning Herald list of
best-sellers. Mr Irving funded and fought four legal
battles against the Australian ban, winning two.
Canberra subsequently changed the immigration
law to keep him out. His daughter
is now an Australian citizen, married to an
Australian, and working for the Queensland
Government; nevertheless Mr Howard has announced
that he will change the "next of kin" law too,
if necessary to keep Mr Irving from speaking in
Australia again. He has made
plain it is Mr Irving's views -- which do
NOT involve the Nazi
Holocaust -- that he wants to keep Australians
from hearing. His fear shows the clout that
these traditional enemies of free speech
have. Mr Irving has informed the National Press
Club on July 18, 2004: "My visit to NZ is on my
own initiative, and I am not invited by, or
speaking to, any groups. I am arranging the
venues myself. "As for a topic, unless you have a choice, I
would suggest something like "The problems of
writing about World War II in a free society."
But I am an expert on Hitler and Churchill, the
subjects of my great biographies. May I make
plain that I will not talk about the Holocaust,
as I am not an expert on that subject. You can
download a leaflet
just printed which gives very useful
quotations. "You can also find some useful
quotations from the High Court judgment in
my libel action against Deborah Lipstadt -- or
read the full
Judgment; all my books are available
as free downloads. "I have of course followed all recent events
in NZ closely, including the Joel
Hayward and the New Zealand Herald cartoonist
affair, and post them hourly on my website. As
for the affair
of the two Mossad agents, [NZ Prime
Minister] Helen Clark seems to have
balls."
Dossier:
attempts by New Zealand Jews to stop David
Irving's 2004 visit |