David
Irving |
Correspondence
between the National University of Ireland (NUIG)
in Galway students and David Irving, inviting him
to speak, then withdrawing the invitation under
pressure Thursday, January 8, 2009 - The
Invitation
-
- The
Literary and Debating Society
- 162nd Session
- Nunc Nunc Qui Timet Eloqui
- Estd. 1846
Dear Mr. Irving I
AM contacting you on behalf of the Literary
& Debating Society of the National
University of Ireland, Galway to argue your
position on the details of the Nazi Holocaust at
a debate hosted by our society. The Lit & Deb (as it is commonly known),
heading into its 162nd year, is a student
organisation which is the largest and oldest in
the university. We provide a forum for free
speech and debate where students and staff can
challenge the issues of the day, practicing the
skills of oratory and critical thinking.
Everything from politics and human rights to
literature and sport are fair game for
discussion inside the walls of the Literary and
Debating Society. With our weekly debates, guest
speaker and literary events, Lit & Deb
offers an enriched experience of university,
outside of the confines of lectures and exam
halls. We would like to invite you to explain your
ideas, present evidence for them and allow them
to be challenged by a member of the Department
of History, here in NUI Galway. We believe that
your right to speak and students right to hear
what have to say is essential to a free and open
society. The Lit & Deb's role in our
university is promote this fundamentally
important right for speech to be free without
qualifying factors of popularity and
palatability. When we define which minority
opinion can be heard and which cannot, democracy
is not truly representing the people who live
under it. It is institutions like the Lit &
Deb and individuals like you, Mr. Irving, which
challenge this flexibility and strength. Unfortunately, that flexibility and strength
has not been upheld in recent events. I refer,
in particular, to your scheduled appearance at
our equivalent society in University College
Cork. It is clear, there are those who oppose
your theories on the holocaust, to the extent
that they would not want you to speak at all.
There are these people in our university as
there is in any. The limits of freedom of speech
and where a society or a university should draw
the line is a debate in and of itself and, in
order to give your appearance at our society the
legitimacy it needs to go ahead successfully, we
will have a referendum of our members before the
event, similar to what they did in the Oxford
Union. It is our hope that by doing this, your
own appearance can then be about explaining your
ideas and will not be needlessly bogged down in
questions over whether or not your free speech
should be permitted. The Society would host you in a hotel in
Galway city centre for the duration of your stay
and cover all transport and accommodation costs.
We will guarantee your safety and the safety of
the audience and if this cannot be provided on
campus, as was the case in UCC, we will move
then event off campus and employ a private
security company. Thank you very much for taking the time to
consider this invitation. We hope that you will
agree in principal to speak at our society and
submit your theories to the rigour of fair and
open debate so that people can decide for
themselves what they believe. The referendum, I
believe, will pass because in our experience,
most people are curious and wish to scrutinise.
They want to hear all sides of the story before
they make up their minds and are naturally
suspicious of having some information filtered
out through censorship before they can hear
it. This year will mark a turning point for our
Society. We aim to involve more students than
ever in public speaking and analytical,
political thinking. We envisage your visit
should you agree to come to be a further
highlight. I have attached a PDF for more
information on the Literary and Debating Society
and please to not hesitate to get in touch if
you have any further questions. Yours sincerely, - Dan Colley
- Auditor
- 162nd Session
- Literary & Debating Society
- National University of Ireland, Galway.
10:23 a.m Windsor, UK, Thursday, January
8, 2009 I
accept of course your very kind invitation, and
the sooner we agree on dates the better, as my
year's calendar soon fills and it becomes
increasingly complicated. Throw some dates (or
periods) at me, and we can nail this down today.
We can then discuss security, an important issue
unfortunately.
Thursday, January 22, 2009 I
am wondering about the outcome of the "debate on
the debate", and whether the invitation is going
ahead; I do have to make plans around it, of
course, and in good time.
Mr Irving inquires, Wednesday, March 11,
2009 literaryanddebating@gmail.com Either your security is 100% or something
untoward has happened to your planned Galway
debate? I have not heard from you for some time,
and am growing concerned, as we also have plans
to fit in at this end, and so far we have
reserved those days for you. Please keep me up
to date with the debate and above all with the
travel planning!
Wednesday, March 11, 2009: I'm
afraid we do have a problem though it's not
security. From the week when the motion was
passed on 22nd of January, up until yesterday,
we have had great trouble finding and opposition
speaker who was both willing and available to
speak at this debate. While there were a number
of interesting and qualified speakers but none
were available for the 19thMarch. Yesterday we
decided that it was not going to happen in time
and would like to postpone the debate until
September/October when we will have a good
opposition speaker in place. I am very sorry indeed for this last-minute
change in your schedule that we have had to
impose and the inconvenience it must cause you.
I hope that you are available in
September/October either August 24, 2009 or the
October 1, 2009. Would either of those dates be
amenable to you? Once again, I apologise for this
inconvenience but I hope you agree that it's for
the sake of the having the best possible debate
on the issue of the Holocaust. Best, Dan Colley - The Literary and Debating Society
- 162nd Session
- Nunc Nunc Qui Timet Eloqui
Estd. 1846
Mr Irving replies, Wednesday, March 11,
2009 literaryanddebating@gmail.com I
am very sorry to hear that. I appreciate that
you have had difficulties, but leaving me in the
dark until just one week ahead of the function
was not good. Only this morning I have had to
reject two important ... appointments made for
March 19 and 20, as I had set aside those dates
for Galway. I keep my promises. I advised you in January when you made this
fixture that my calendar-year fills up very
quickly, and I cannot guarantee you any firm
dates in September or October 2009. If you will
contact me closer to the dates you re-plan this
event, I will see if I can fit you in. Again, this is frustrating. Had I booked
hotels and air tickets I would be out of pocket;
this has now left a hole in my calendar which I
would have used differently.
September 11, 2009: My
name is Robin Allen, and I am the auditor of the
National University of Ireland, Galway, Food
& Drink Society. I have emailed you in the
past concerning the reasoning behind our
Literary & Debating Society failed attempt
to organise your appearance in a safe and
controlled manner By now you may have guessed that I am about
to make the same request. In fact, the request
is more so to have a discussion on the finer
things in life, such as food, wine and
lifestyles, and of course you will be given an
ample chance to air your views and defend your
position. While I may not agree with you, after
the failed appearance there was a building
outcry to allow freedom of speech and so I
decided that I would be morally remiss if I were
to deny the many what they desire because of the
actions of the few. If you are interested in discussing this
further, feel free to contact me so as to
discuss this further, if not, thank you for your
time. - Yours,
- Robin
Allen
- Auditor, N.U.I, Galway Food & Drink
Society
The
Invitation WithdrawnSeptember 30, 2009: The National University of Ireland in
Galway has finally cancelled the
invitation:
I regret to inform you that we have to
permanently cancel your visit to the Literary
and Debating Society at the National University
of Ireland, Galway. As you are aware, we
postponed the event last March as we had been
unable to secure a suitable opposition speaker.
We revisited the plan for holding the event at
the beginning of this academic year and
unfortunately the university are not letting us
proceed for safety reasons. The university
authorities carried out a safety review which
included consideration of the reaction to the
planned debate on various websites and
consultation with security personnel with
relevant experience in other universities. On
the basis of this review, the Vice-President for
Physical Resources informed us that, in his
capacity as Director of Safety, he was unable to
permit use of the University's facilities for
the debate on the grounds that there would be an
unacceptable risk to the safety and well-being
of security staff, students and others who might
be in attendance. My apologies. - Jacqueline Driscoll,
- Auditor,
- Literary and Debating Society
- 163rd Session
- National University of Ireland, Galway
David Irving comments: "These enemy tactics are
difficult to counter, and would succeed totally
were it not for the Internet: Smear and silence
by threats of violence."
-
Our
dossier on the Origins of
Anti-Semitism
-
Irish
National University, Galway, forced to withdraw
invitation to David Irving to
speak
-
visit
by controversial historian cancelled
due to 'security concerns
Website
support: contribute
once
|
regularly
|