Index to Readers’ Letters 1998-1999

Index to Readers’
Letters 1998-1999

[see too Index to letters,
1998-1999 | 2000-01
| 2002 | 2003
| 2004 | current
]

• Donald Roy
  Miller writes how much he admires our website and
  why
• Paul Grubach writes that
  Hitler did want Final Solution postponed
• Frank Grimm
  says Prisoners in Siberia were not allowed to send
  postcards home
• Mr Irving’s opponents base
  their case on interpretations not facts
• Drilling down deeper into
  Jan Karski | “Candide”
  asks was Karski raised as a Jew? | In
  Defence of Jan Karski | Ted
  O’Keefe adds his two ha’porth | Heath
  replies to O’Keefe |

  Jan
  Karski Dies: Pole who brought word of Holocaust |
  O’Keefe responds to Heath on
  Belzec | Lowdown on the
  late Jan Karski | Ted
  O’Keefe adds more | Michael
  Mills sees More problems with believing Jan Karski |
  Jan Wasilewski tells us what
  Karski reported in 1940 | Alan
  Lloyd gives the lowdown

  on Jan Karski

• Appelbaum
  and the ‘compromise’ with dissident historians
• Questions on the last
  days of Hitler
• Clint Willson
  says, Keep Bashing Prof. Evans
• All
  Spies incl. Pollard should suffer Death Penalty
• Brian Renk: The
  enemy are publishing books on the Lipstadt trial already;
  are we?
• Adrian Jensen
  asks, Why be rude about Prof. Lipstadt?

  Was she a
  liar?

• A baffled Australian
  reader asks: Why are Irving books available here
  free?
• Brian Manuel whined to
  his girlfriend about how to get Irving books …
• Historian Adam Meath,
  Australia, expresses respect for Mr Irving’s quest to
  restore objectivity to the historiography of
  Hitler
• Clint Willson reports
  more role playing requried of US schoolchildren
• Mark Gallmeier writes on the
  Churchill estate’s censored legacy
• Paul
  McDermott criticises

  Tim Sebastian of BBC

• Ahmed Rami’s
  stupid 1992 prank backfires
• A. Stadlen was in Court when Mr Irving spoke the
  words “mein Führer”
• How the History
  Channel manipulates, uh, history
• Richard Duffy
  writes from Bangkok, Thailand, on the folly of attacking
  the Traditional Enemies of the Truth
• F
  Gain recalls bombing and strafing of Dresden,
  1945
• Stefan de Batselier
  saw a BBC programme about a Jewish ex-slave worker in
  Buna, Auschwitz
• Prof.

  Richard Evans: If the price is right

• Lipstadt’s
  references to Mr Irving as a bug and to “pest control”
  recall other prominent Jews’ usage of such
  metaphors
• Niall
  McNamara writes from Dublin, Ireland, about American
  Libraries Association policies
• Chris
  Turkington on the problem with Burning bodies with 3.5kg
  of coke | Reinhard
  Tixel on the same problem
• A S Marques
  writes about Van Pelt on the “moral
  certainty” of the Auschwitz gas

  chambers

• Dear
  Scumbag, and other letters received after the Apr 2000
  Lipstadt trial
• Bill Ternan
  panned The War Between the
  Generals for Newsday, now he wishes he
  hadn’t
• Lipstadt is
  arguing the end of revisionism must be done in her
  lifetime, otherwise the job might not get done
  properly
• Why should I
  support David Irving?, asks Christoph Schuringa
• LSE Black
  student writes: If we had 1000 David Irvings the world
  will a better

  place

• Mike Hourston
  says David Irving’s summation provided sufficient light
  on the issues, but will people be willing to use that
  light?
• A professor
  expresses horror when a US student selects a David Irving
  book to review
• A Student of
  Emory University Comments on the Lipstadt trial
• Tony — stumbles across a
  site about Nobel Laureate Elie Wiesel
• Steven
  Piper (USA) is horrified at the nightmare inflicted on Mr
  Irving
• US
  Army officer praises

  meticulous research of Irving
  books

• Adam Kendir
  reports praise for our trial coverage by Prof.

  Peter
  Hoffmann of Montreal

• The
  Anti-Zionist Conference scheduled for Sweden in November
  1992, and the JTA and Lipstadt lies
• John Coffey read
  the transcripts, and writes: “What a feast!”
• Larry Rayko is
  amazed at the depth and breath of the conspiracy against
  Real History
• Denmark
  thanks Mr Irving for taking the time to give a free
  download of Hitler’s War
• Support from an
  Israeli for FAZ reporting of Lipstadt trial
• Why are Irving
  books suppressed yet

  Amazon.com sells
  MEIN KAMPF and Henry Ford’s The
  International Jew?

• An Australian
  Steve Wolfe relates (18.2.00) how he typed Germany into a
  search-engine and stumbled across this site
• Wolf
  Rüdiger, son of Rudolf Hess writes us about Lipstadt
  trial
• On
  CNN Abraham Foxman (ADL) claimed to be a Holocaust
  Survivor.

  But he was never in a concentration
  camp

• Jerry Meng says
  the greatest criminal is not Adolf Hitler, but Joseph
  Stalin
• A Dr Stone mocks
  Mr Irving for suing, not taking criticism
• Who is Funding
  Professor Lipstadt’s Defence? – No Surprises
• Claudio Franciosi has praise
  for David Irving’s book Apocalypse 1945: the Destruction
  of Dresden
• A reader has facts on when
  Ribbentrop offered to die for Germany in April
  1945
• Kimberly Cornish proves that

  Vienna
  schoolboy Ludwig Wittgenstein, the great philospher, was
  indeed the object of Adolf Hitler’s very first recorded
  anti-Semitic epithet

• John Dietrich want
  facts on Lord Cherwell and the Second Quebec
  Conference Sept 1944
• Trinity College, Dublin, student newspaper asks
  about the cancellation of the lecture David Irving at
  University College Cork
• Sebastian Barnard feels that
  Historians
  should now concentrate on the “Why?”
• Katrina Mitchell asks: Did
  Professor

  Heisenberg want to build the atomic bomb; or
  did he just conceal his failure?

• Canadian Association
  of Journalists website which reports on Canada’s police
  state activities against press
• Luigi Capano asks Is it
  true that Picasso started his Guernica painting years
  before the air raid on Guernica?
• A Mr Smith asks how
  he can help finance the fight
• A scholar and hater
  has spelling problems
• A computer expert in Berlin asks: Why
  are no German editions of David

  Irving books available as
  free downloads?

• Hatemail from Daniel
  Mycyk, an Australian Pole, about Auschwitz earns an
  appropriate response
• Sam Boland of University College, Cork, asks

  on Nov
  21, 1999 if Mr Irving
  speaks to rightwing extremist groups as foes
  allege

• Fabio Gianfelici asks why
  J.C. Pressac’s book Technique and Operation of Gas
  Chambers is impossible to find
• Alan Heath, Warsaw, claims there
  has never been any suggestion that the gas chamber at
  Auschwitz was anything but a reconstruction
• TV documentary on Nuremberg
  Trials claims Mauthausen had a gas chamber.

  Did
  it?

• John Ball asks why fake
  photos are being removed after 4 years, and just one
  month before the Wehrmacht exhibit moves to America?
• Donald Siano spots errors
  in Hitler’s War download
• Eric de Chalain of Australia thanks
  this website for the free downloads of complete David
  Irving books
• An Icelander Dr.

  Gudbrandur Jonasson became
  a personal friend of Heinrich Himmler (in the
  1920s).

• Hugh McInnish asks if
  Churchill mentioned the Holocaust in his WWII
  volumes?
• Chris Goodall has questions
  on Hitler’s Henchmen and their Children
• Elisabet, of Spain, wants
  to contact a Holocaust survivor, for a school project
• Sharon Fleischmann asks, Did
  Hitler visit the Nazi concentration camps?
• When a man
  of your stature speaks people listen, writes an Ottawa
  law student.

  Are you absolutely sure that there were
  no gas chambers?

• Alvaro Neto reports that the Portuguese network
  Telepac is blocking this website on the false pretext
  that it is an adult (i.e.

  pornographic) website

• A reader comments on the Sept 1999 History
  Channel film on Dresden air raid 1945
• Arthur Butz is grateful
  that we put David Irving’s Nuremberg book on the web
  for free download
• Reinhard Tixel watches the History
  Channel documentary on the fake Hitler Diaries and
  notices that David Irving is never mentioned
• Bill Wood writes to David Irving,
  I let the silence of all of the murdered speak for
  me
• Michel Mills comments on
  the 1948 German

  newsreel of a Polish war-crimes court
  judgement that “altogether nearly 300,000 died at
  Auschwitz”

• William Beaver denies that the
  famous flag raising on Mount Suribachi (Iwo Jima) was
  carefully posed
• Arthur Hawley says, it’s wrong to say
  ball point pens weren’t available until 1951
• Paul Fritz-Nemeth thinks
  David Irving’s Nuremberg, the Last Battle the best book
  he has written
• Jewish NKVD torturers
  committed crimes against Lithuanian partisans and
  civilians,

  writes John Bedarfas

• Gene asks is David Irving
  author of The book ‘The German Atomic Bomb’
• A London rabbi asks us about proofs
  that Hitler ordered the extermination of the Jews, and
  the value of survivor testimony
• Matt Nuenke has created a website
  on the 20th Century Genocide Museum and seeks other
  groups trying to publicize The Great Terror, the
  Ukrainian famine
• Jewish NKVD torturers
  committed against Lithuanian partisans and innocent
  civilians, writes John

  Bedarfas

• Robert Reis asks if John Keegan
  prefers to admire public courage from a safe
  distance
• A London rabbi asks about proofs
  that Hitler ordered the extermination of the Jews, and
  the value of survivor testimony
• Do you foresee any
  future functions a bit closer to North Carolina? asks
  Teresa Taylor
• Philip Smith of Chicago wonders
  if New York Times article is intended as advance damage
  control
• Phoebe asks: “If Anne
  Frank didn’t completely write her

  diary, then who
  did?”

• Dan from Canada finds
  disproportionate reference to his country on this
  (British) Website
• Nizkor’s Ken McVay
  disappointed that Mr Irving has not followed through on
  his thinly veiled threat of a libel lawsuit
• Yugoslav Jews in Canada object to this Website
  reporting on their complaint
  to Canadian Jewish Congress
• Yolanda Flanagan suggests that some
  Jews hated the Poles more than they hated the
  Nazis
• Michael Howard thinks that The

  Darwin Awards
  give
  ammunition to Mr Irving’s critics

• Frank Idzikowski writes a
  letter from Arizona — about Clinton and Serbia
• Joe Bachelder asks for information about Germany’s
  sites of interest
  relating to Hermann Göring
• David Kramer writes
  about
  a recent dinner party…
• Bernie Mueller asks why Canada
  Customs has detained some David Irving books he
  ordered
• Kirie Pedersen asks for an explanation
  of David Irving’s libel suit against

  Gitta
  Sereny

• Matt Giwer writes about Jamie McCarthy,
  who opposes mindless censorship — but
  selectively
• Nato’s
  missiles are not so smart, writes Marco de
  Innocentis
• Sidney Carton tells us of an article in New Repuiblic
  calling for www.amazon.com
  to censor its books on WW.II
• John Bryant inquires

  on Apr 10, 1999 about the
  Adolf Eichmann Papers and a Hitler order to
  exterminate the Jews

• Dr Anthony J Lomenzo writes on the
  arrest of Fredrick Toben
• Joe Homenko, Sydney, wonders whether Toben is
  trying too hard
  to be a martyr
• A-level scholar Susan Toft of the UK asks, Apr 10,
  1999: why do they call Mr
  Irving a holocaust denier?
• An Austrian correspondent reports how police raided
  her for possessing
  a 1989 tape of a David Irving lecture…

  [in
  German]

• Thomas Weyersberg writes from Quebec, Jul 29, 1998:
  nightmare recollections
  of the air raid on Dresden
• Lauren needs to know for her English class how
  many people Hitler is responsible for killing
• Michael Mills quotes an inoccuous example
  of the use of the word “Sonderaktion”
• Michael S., of Cumbria, asks about the doctoring
  of the Nuremberg trial transcripts
• A fan letter from
  Paul Christus, Germany
• Stavros Elia, UK A-level student,

  asks: “Was
  there a systematic Nazi Plan to exterminate the Jewish
  race from 1933 and how significant was Hitler in
  this?”

• Marco de Innocentis, of Durham, UK, writes
  about Prof R
  J Van Pelt; and the injustice to General Remer’s
  widow
• Brian B.

  of York, Pennsylvania, has a query
  about racial superiority, Feb 23, 1999

• Albert Doyle writes about the
  Blumenthal-Hitchens feud on Monday, Feb 22, 1999
• High school student Amy Kocher asks about
  the Dresden raid
• 10th Grader Katie has questions
  about Hitler and religion
• David Miller has the latest
  news on Australia’s “good character” requirements for
  visitors, January 27, 1999
• Jamie McCarthy
  is angry that David Irving has not answered him
• Jeffrey

  Anderson (USA) asks when Hitler’s War
  will be reprinted; David Irving tells
  the extraordinary story behind the book . . . and
  asks for solid investment capital

• Rob Ross suggests ways to exploit the lawsuit against
  Lipstadt … and David Irving replies
• Jim Dean
  of Atlanta asks what is a “Holocaust Denier?”
• Robert Lause of
  Adelaide asks Dec. 14, 1998 about Treblinka and Babi
  Yar
• Dawana Jo Murphy of Arizona, Dec.

  7, 1998, is
  concerned about the loss of
  free speech in Germany

• Newcastle student Emma Svanberg has questions
  about the Holocaust, which David Irving addresses,
  December 6, 1998
• John Kyle, on actor
  Carlos Thompson’s curious attack on David Irving.
• Auschwitz-I
  commandant’s daughter, writes that her mother says
  “those [crematoria] were not there”
• Rudolf Weisse, a
  Stalingrad veteran, writes October 22,
  1998 [German]
• “Samuel Crowell”
  comments on Auschwitz

  interrogations

• Dr J M Andrade makes
  a point about the Rudolf Hess plane
• David Katz
  (South Africa) still has a bee in his bonnet about
  recollections of a 1987 lecture in Johannesburg
  [now with a photo of that meeting] |
  Earlier letters exchanged with Katz,
  February 2-3, 1998
• Fariz from Malaysia,
  October 12, 1998, asks about the 1983 Fake Hitler Diaries
  scandal
• Stan Hargus writes from
  the USA about the Riga massacres (1941), Bruns — and

  Jim
  Bacque

• Roy Wells writes from
  Fleckney, Leicestershire, about BBC television picture
  fakery on The 1940 Blitz
• A Norwegian asks if
  Rudolf Hess was murdered
• Readers comment
  on David Irving’s diary coverage of his libel action
  against Deborah Lipstadt
• Albert Doyle’s own
  investigations into the Dachau massacre
• Correspondence with the
  late Professor Klaus J Herrmann, of Montreal
  university, about Nazi concentration camps and
  evidence.
• Harold T

  has
  written a book about Kurt Waldheim entitled The
  Anatomy of a Witch Hunt.

• Gary Goodenowdoubts the authenticity of the Hitler guns offered
  for sale, September 9, 1998
• Dr John Fox comments on
  Christian Gerlach’s thesis about the December 18, 1941
  Himmler document
• Pawel Szalamacha
  writes from Poland, August 31, 1998: did the Polish
  cavalry charge Nazi tanks in 1939?
• Professor Hans
  Mommsen writes from Germany pleading with this
  Website not to quote his

  1978 praise for David
  Irving

• Lawrence
  Starr, United States, feels that the international
  Right-wing is flailing ineffectually.
• Anneliese Remer, widow
  of army General Otto Ernst Remer writes from her enforced
  exile in Marbella, Spain
• Art Kleps suggests
  turning New York City over to “terrorist leader” Bin
  Laden.
• Lawrence Starr
  makes allegations, August 23, 1998 about criminal records
  of National Alliance members in Cleveland.
• Jeff Kledis asks
  questions

  about the embarrassing Potocki Papers published
  by the Nazis in 1940.

• Review of a Lazar
  Kaganovich biography, The Wolf of the Kremlin,
  by Stuart Kahan.
• A Scandinavian Friend
  writes a scathing commentary on the kaleidoscope of
  killing methods used during the Holocaust.
• A reader comments, August
  3, 1998, on an inaccuracy in David Irving’s press
  release on being banned from Auschwitz.
• Alan Moses, of Tampa,
  Florida, July 26, 1998, on the Australian and

  Auschwitz
  bans on David Irving.

• David Kramer,
  a New York Jew, joins the doubters, July 24, and
  August 10,
  1998.
• J Taylor, London,
  comments on Website, July 14, 1998
• Samuel Crowell,
  United States, Sunday, July 8, 1998: Ron Rosenbaum’s new
  book Explaining Hitler.
• Paul W has produced a
  CD-Rom of Nazi concentration camp pictures.

  And (July 4,
  1998) remarks on a door at the US Holocaust Memorial
  Museum, Washington

• Terry Rumbel, July 3,
  1998 about Hitler’s War and Stuka-ace Hans-Ulrich
  Rudel
• Nicolas Alvarez, in
  Chile, asks how he can purchase Spanish language books by
  David Irving.
• Gilbert Gendron
  writes from Montreal, July 1, 1998: did Hitler in fact
  ever talk of a “1,000 Year Reich”?

  Another reader
  replies.

• Ivan Marchevsky
  writes from Veliko Tarnovo, June 21, 1998 about
  references to Bulgaria in Hitler’s War.
• Alexander Mayer,
  Jewish-born Director of Progen, (“Project Genocide”), of
  New Brunswick, New Jersey, writes

  on June 21, 1998, about
  Romanian documents suggesting that Hitler did know
  of Final Solution; and June
  22, 1998 [updated July 10] about the
  possibiity that Auschwitz deportees were sent to
  Transnistria instead.

• Maureen Bower of
  Ontario writes June 19, 1998 about the role of Masons in
  the British legal system.
• Frank Lowe, North
  Carolina, June 8, 1998: the underground War by Typhus in
  WW2 Poland; with a commentary by Samuel

  Crowell.

• Eric de
  Chalain, South Africa: Mr Irving to lecture
  there?
• Samuel Crowell,
  United States, Sunday, May 17, 1998: Auschwitz,
  Höss, Warsaw Ghetto.
• Frank Paulson of
  Texas comments on Hitler’s War, May 7, 1998.
• A former Berkeley
  student, April 27, 1998, expresses anger that he was
  denied the right to hear David Irving at UCB in
  1994.
• “Samuel Crowell,”
  United States, Friday, March 21, 1998: comments on this
  site’s

  documentation.

• Albert Doyle, United
  States, Friday, March 20, 1998: on the Vatican’s
  role.
• Robert E Reis, United
  States, March 19, 1998: the Himmler Diaries.
• Robert
  Gilmor, United States, March 15, 1998: on book
  ordering, and David Irving’s next speaking
  functions.
• Grant G.,
  Australia, March 13, 1998: Nazi persecution of the Jews.

  On Auschwitz see
  our file [full name removed at his request].

• Kenneth McVay (“Nizkor
  Project”) denies receiving funding from the ADL, March 1,
  1998
• Correspondence with ADL-member
  Ronald Jacobs about Nazi concentration camps and
  evidence, 1997
• Ken Thornton, June
  29, 1998, attended the event at Washington State
  university

[ Index to letters, 1998-1999
| 2000-2001 |
2002 | current
]