The Auschwitz Letters (HnetAuschwStories)

[H-Net
Humanities & Social Sciences
OnLine]

---

Meals at Auschwitz

Re:
The Sonderkommando and the process of learning

Author: Richard Prystowsky <[email protected]>
Date: Wed, 10 Feb 1999 19:14:20 +0000

Reply-To: H-NET List for History of the Holocaust
<[email protected]> Sender: H-NET List for History of the Holocaust
<[email protected]>

I recall one survivor telling one of my classes that there was no living or dying in Auschwitz (he survived
Birkenau), because there was no life or death there as we know it.

He also mentioned that, at one point, he had heard a rumor that, before going into the gas chamber, the victim was given a good meal (in light of current practices involving state executions in this country, this rumor is quite provocative and frightening). He presented himself at the next selection as someone unfit for further work.
He asked to be taken away.

Fortunately–or unfortunately, as he might well say, depending upon how on a given day he thinks about his survival (I know him rather well and have discussed this topic with him a number of times)–the doctor refused to send him to the gas chamber.

Paraphrase, with some exact quotes here:

“You mean that you wanted to die?” asked a student.

“You see? You just can’t possibly hope to understand–and that’s not your fault. It isn’t that I wanted to die. I just wanted to have a good meal.”

“You cannot imagine how it feels to be so hungry,” this survivor told me once during an “official” interview.

He’s right. So how do I hear his words? I begin by trying to hear them.

Richard
J. Prystowsky Acting Dean, School of Humanities and Languages Irvine Valley College
5500 Irvine Center Drive Irvine, CA 92620 949-451-5336

---

From: John Freund <[email protected]>

February 11, 1999

I do not believe the story of a meal being served to those to die in the gaschamber. This is utter nonsense.
And even those terribly hungry, never would prefer death.
Besides, those working Sonderkommandos always had enough to eat. I was “living” in a barrack next to the SK in
Birkenau, with about 80 boys my age ( 14 ) and we sneaked into their barrack at night to get some food. This was strictly forbidden.

Does anyone have an idea, how the thousands could have been fed a meal before dying?

John
Freund.

[H-Net
Humanities & Social Sciences OnLine] Send comments and questions to H-Net
Webstaff Copyright
© 1995-98, H-Net, Humanities & Social Sciences
OnLine Click Here for an Internet
Citation Guide.

---

Auschwitz
Index
| current
AR-Online

Comment:
security at Birkenau around the gas-chambers does not
appear to have been very strict.

To
Order Books
| Auschwitz
Index |
Irving
Index |
Irving
Page |
Irving
Book-List
| Action
Report
| Other
FP Authors

Buchladen
| Auschwitz
| Irving-Verzeichnis
| -Hauptseite
| -Bücher
| Action
Report
| Weitere
FP-Autoren©Focal
Point 1998 write to David Irving