Quick navigationMr. Irving, take me to …… your current newsletter… readers’ letters 1989-1999… readers’ letters 2000-2001… readers’ letters 2002… readers’ letters 2003… readers’ letters 2004… your main alphabetical index… news on your legal battles… you and your family… your career so far… how to buy your books… free downloads of your books… how to help your fighting fund… your letters to the press… your publishing Home Page Index to Readers’ Letters 2004 [see too Index to letters, 1998-1999 | 2000-01 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | current ] : John Miller asks if the published diaries of General Gerhard Engel, Hitler’s army adjutant are genuine, and gets a full reply Paul J.M. Sweet shares our views on Prof Richard ‘Skunky’ EvansRoad directions to the site of Hermann Göring’s (now demolished) fabulous hunting lodge, Carinhall Arturo Ramirez praises Mr Irving’s book on the feud between Eisenhower and Montgomery Korham Gulgun inquires about stories on a Peter Stahl website that Mr Irving fakes documents Serge Romanov is unimpressed by the much vaunted Yad Vashem website database on Holocaust survivor statistics William B disagrees on America’s recent military adventures: Nobody profits from a badly run war Oxford undergraduate asks if it is safe to reference Mr Irving’s books in his submissions Peter Eastman delves into the history of an ancestor who served with Mr Irving’s father at Jutland and in Antarctic discovery expeditions Marcos de Escobar of Rio de Janeiro agrees with Mr Irving on the immigrant invasion of England Brian Carlson shares Radical’s Diary view on the Iraq war Doron G of Los Angeles lectures Mr Irving on the gentle graces and great virtues of Israel and its inhabitants Judith Stefchak of Alaska thinks Mr Irving is a bigger liar than the Australia ASSHOL “Bernhard Holstein” Aubrey Soper has better information on the May 1945 loss of the German liner Cap Arcona Aubrey Soper argues that Iraqi farmers are fair game for helicopter gunships | and he still insists he is right Barry Smith has further comment on Mr Irving’s motives in offering to settle the Lipstadt action out of court | Brian Hillman thinks the two offers were spurious | Richard Santana believes that Mr Irving wanted to make a killing from the trial George Vel asks questions about David Olère’s alleged ‘eye-witness’ sketches of Auschwitz | but David Hebden suggests that Olère really was at Auschwitz | Oskar Feder offers three more of ‘Auschwitz survivor’ Olère’s pictures of life at the camp | Frank Lowe fills in the details on the “SS doctor” sketch | RLM comments on more Olère errors Critique of Auschwitz photo of two women leading a troop of kids ‘to the gas chambers’ Where did US official report on 9/11 give facts on al-Qaida’s anti-Israel prime motivation? Stewart Donovan expresses uncontrolled glee at what he sees as Mr Irving’s misfortunes Mike Kilroy has comments on Albert Camus and the Lipstadt trial Yannis Natsinas asks what led to the death of Gauleiter Gustav Simon Swedish student Henrik asks for sources on Hitler’s ideology Britt and Keri Singleton comment on a gun-camera video from the attack on Afghanistan Frank Lowe on Höss’s testimony on Gassings at Auschwitz Leor Leon of Israel rather likes the works of Mr Irving Ivan Brkich asks important questions about the Holocaust on behalf of students at his Australian college George Brennan has some questions about Holocaust history Gene Mangrum disagrees that the 9/11 hijackers were intrepid Were Japanese steamers were ordered home before Pearl Harbor William Sterling Jr wants Mr Irving to suppress opinions about ethnic groups Tom Stoneburner doubts there are many real anomalies about 9/11 ‘Concerned citizen’ Barry Smith implores New Zealand’s minister of immigration to keep Mr Irving out Joanna Sanders of New Zealand has now decided to obtain all Mr Irving’s books Uri K, of Moscow, Russia, speaks up for the embattled oligarchs, suggesting that things are not always criminal as they seem Michael Deutsch of New Zealand would discourage Mr Irving from visiting “his” country Maxine Fisher finds Goebbels biography patiently researched, without the customary bias and bitterness Brian Hillman accuses Mr Irving of anti-Semitism in his comments on the Russian oligarchs A Texas fireman, describes how his team did find relics of the Columbia space shuttle Peter Wakefield Sault thinks the story of Mossad looting an ancient Iraqi library is apocryphal James Roberts has a suggestion for preventing a terrorism cover-up the next time David Irving’s mother wrote a famous children’s book, The Dawnchild: a reader inquires James Huddleston recalls how Mr Irving’s book on 1956 uprising gave Hungarian people hope Robert Barnaby asks if Sonderkommando men wore a dogtag? Richard Hughey comments that Mr Irving ‘took the Fifth’ in the PQ.17 libel trial in 1970 Dr Andrew Mathis accuses Mr Irving of endorsing thuggish behaviour Clint Swift thinks that Prof Richard Evans is so cool, compared with the [expletive] Mr Irving Erwin Maruna asks about a rogue reference to Mr Irving in the alleged memoirs of Nicholas von Below Churchill’s historic phrase ‘Iron Curtain’: goes back to Signal, 1943, says Alex Zöller Hater Bradley R. Gilchrist thinks that Mr Irving should be ‘cleansed’ Glennon W. Simmons disagrees with Mr Irving’s remarks on US troops in Afghanistan | and an immediate reply Ron Kurtz reveals Churchill’s unlikely source for the historic phrase ‘Iron Curtain’ Gonzalo Baeza asks what we think of Peter Padfield’s biography of Himmler Lewis Graham says ‘Hitler’ was great; when do we get to finish ‘Churchill’? Gregory Rose asks for Mr Irving’s postion on the Einsatz Reinhardt camps, and gets not much of an answer Chinese expatriate Sissi Wu has praise for the battle for Real History John D Boyle of Washington state takes issue with this website’s portrayal of the war in Iraq Prof Philip Kirstein warns that the growing censorship of academics suggests a New McCarthyism Vydyanath writes from India about Mr Irving’s books which he is downloading free, and asks about Mein Kampf The Holocaust: James Cowell asks for good archival sources which answer the question, what did the German people know, and when did they know it? Bob Liepa asks about Hitler’s pen: did it have the Star of David? John Smith asks questions, not always answered Douglas Rees spotted the General-Patton-and-his-niece story in The War Between the Generals Charles Ziembo is impressed by Churchill’s War, and urges Mr Irving to keep on writing Alex asks about new editions of Churchill’s War, Goebbels, and other David Irving titles Barry Klazura likes Churchill’s War, dislikes Hitler Trina McCandless has hope: she hopes Mr Irving drowns A schoolteacher in South Africa would like advice on textbooks on World War Two What is the truth about Churchill and the 1940 raid on Coventry? Frank Lowe Jr comments on Dr Christopher Browning’s interview on the Final Solution ‘Mel Fowler has read a 1990 speech by David Irving to the Clarendon Club Colin McInnis asks how many Soviet casualties there really were in WW2 Bob Johnson and Juliusz Jablecki ask questions about entries in the Goebbels diaries, used by conformist historians writing about the Holocaust Sean Buhr asks what happened to Hitler’s chief henchman Martin Bormann? Pat of New York has spotted an odd thing about French news bulletins from Iraq: Is Washington rationing what dumb US viewers get to see? Wilma Kamp of San Diego, California, asks for our readers’ help on jewellery attributed to Eva Braun Sheila Lynn bought a used copy of an Irving book tossed out by a US Army library A Reader visited Edinburgh bookstores asking for David Irving books, but is told that such ‘anti-Semitic’ material is not sold there Dick Earley comments on the ratio of Jews who fought for Germany in WW1 to WW2 A Reader has advice to Windows users on how to download the free books Kelly Snowden can’t believe that anybody can find the constant whining about the Holocaust is boring Why didn’t these 735 Norwegian Jews, among them my grand parents, my uncles, aunts and cousins, return to Norway? On the Zyklon B controversy: there is no darker place than the mind of a High Court Judge Do you know of any photos of Eva Braun’s home? Sylvie Auguste, French writer has questions about Waldemar Fegelein Ramanujan asks Did Truman know Hiroshima was a civilian target [see too Index to letters, 1998-1999 | 2000-01 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | current ] © Focal Point 2005 David Irving