Friday, October 22, 1999
Auschwitz
memoir a fantasy, publisher
admits FROM ALLAN HALL IN BERLIN AN AWARD-WINNING book
that purported to be the memories of a
Latvian-Jewish man who had survived the
Nazi death camps as a small child is being
removed from German bookshops after its
publishers declared it a hoax. It is
feared the confirmation that Binjamin
Wilkomirski invented the story in
Fragments
will be invoked by the far Right as
evidence that the Holocaust never
happened. Fragments
was published in 1995 to vast acclaim from
critics and the public in America and
Europe. It was seen as a remarkable work
and deeply moving testimony. Wilkomirski claimed to have been
adopted by Swiss parents after the war and
to have had no memory of the Auschwitz and
Majdanek camps and the ghetto at Riga
until this was "recovered" years later by
therapists. Survivors of the Holocaust, and those
who seek to document it, praised the work
highly. It won many literary prizes, and
the author gave lectures all over
America. But a year ago a Swiss writer,
Daniel Ganzfried, whose own father
was an inmate of Auschwitz, started
investigating the author -- who turns
out to have been born in Switzerland, to
be non-Jewish, and to be called Bruno
Dösseker. "I found some of what
he wrote about and the whole repressed
memory thing unbelievable," Mr Ganzfried
said. "I found a birth certificate for him
dated February 12, 1941. He never suffered
in these terrible places set up by the
Nazis." The book's German publishers, Suhrkamp
Verlag, withdrew hardback editions last
week and ceased offering it on its
specialist Jewish imprint list. The
author's agent had decided to do her own
sleuthing to clear his name; but the
historian she hired, Stefan
Mächler, condemned him in a
100-page report. The publishers will make
a final decision about the paperback
shortly but say they have confidence in
the investigation. It is thought that Wilkomirski might
have a psychological syndrome in which he
finds meaning by having survived hell on
earth. Whatever the explanation, he
maintains that the memoir is
true. |