London, Sunday, June 25, 2000
Well connected:
Levy, an accountant, is a close confidant
of Tony Blair Blair
tycoon paid just £5,000 tax
THE millionaire
businessman credited with turning round
the Labour party's finances by raising up
to £7m ahead of the last general
election paid just £5,000 in taxes to
the Inland Revenue last year. Lord Levy, 55, a former music
business mogul and close confidant of the
prime minister, sought but failed on
Friday to obtain a gagging order
preventing The Sunday Times from
publishing this and other details of his
tax affairs. In
a midnight hearing, the High Court ruled
in the newspaper's favour, saying there
was a clear public interest in revealing
the Labour peer's tax secrets because of
the way his party had repeatedly condemned
tax avoidance schemes while in
opposition. "He who actively involves himself in
public life, as Lord Levy has, cannot
altogether complain if he is caught by the
heat," said Mr Justice Toulson in a
ground-breaking ruling. Lord Levy, the former accountant
ennobled [made a
Lord] by Tony Blair in
1997 in recognition of his work in raising
money for the party, consolidated his
fortune in the late 1980s when he sold his
recording business, Magnet Records, for an
estimated £10m. He then founded a
second recording company, M&G Records,
which sold in 1997 for an undisclosed
sum. Levy has now been appointed by Blair as
his "personal envoy" to the Middle
East. Information passed to The Sunday Times
last week reveals that Levy was a
basic-rate taxpayer who paid about the
same to the Inland Revenue in the 1998/99
financial year as someone earning the
national average salary of
£21,000. The leak came in the wake of a story in
last week's paper which revealed how
foreign-born Labour donors are cutting
their tax bills by exploiting a £10
billion loophole through which they can
claim not to be domiciled in the UK for
tax purposes despite having lived and
voted here for decades. Levy's
tiny tax bill will surprise his wide
circle of friends and business associates,
who include Ehud Barak, the Israeli
prime minister,
[right],
and Bernie Ecclestone, the Formula
1 racing tycoon. They know Levy as a self-made
millionaire who drives a Bentley, lives in
a palatial London home complete with
swimming pool and palm trees, and who
boasts of having brought the pop-stars
Chris Rea and Alvin Stardust to fame. The tax bill would also appear to place
a question mark over how much of Levy's
wealth, if any, is held in the sort of tax
avoidance schemes that Labour colleagues
criticised so vehemently before winning
office in 1997. Mike Warburton, senior tax
partner with accountants Grant
Thornton, said: "People with this much
wealth often invest with people like me to
avoid tax but to get it down to the basic
rate is quite extraordinary. "It is possible but would involve
extremely careful and sophisticated
planning." Levy's
multi-million pound London
homeThe leaked information on Levy's
affairs shows that he faced a total
personal UK tax bill of just over
£5,000 for the 1998/99 financial year
- the last year for which he, and most
other people, have completed a tax return.
His taxable income was less than
£20,000. Levy, who started his career as an
accountant, had no capital gains in the
year in question. Only modest income from
shares and other investments, including
interest of about £150 from an
account in Israel, is said to have been
included on his tax return. This is odd, say accountants, because
Levy is known to be a man of substantial
means whose capital would normally be
expected to produce a large annual
return. In Levy's case, no such income is
apparent, raising the question: what has
he done with his money? "It is a mystery.
He must either have the money under his
mattress or it is tied up in investments
that do not produce any income, or it is
held in some sort of trust," said one
leading tax consultant last week. There is no suggestion that Levy has
done anything illegal or improper to avoid
tax and his lawyers explained his low tax
bill on Friday on the grounds that he was
not "gainfully employed" during the year
in question. They added that he was "living on
capital" and denied that he had any
offshore holdings, other than a "small
bank account" and second home in
Israel. Levy had attempted to gag The Sunday
Times with an injunction on the grounds
that his tax affairs were confidential.
However, The Sunday Times successfully
argued that his position as a Labour peer
and his close ties with a government that
before the last election had pledged to
stamp out tax avoidance meant that it was
in the public interest for the facts to
come out. "If the individual had nothing to do
with the Labour party I would have
inclined to the view that the right to
confidentiality should prevail," said Mr
Justice Toulson. "But if the individual has allied
himself to the party to the extent of
taking a peerage and taking the Labour
whip then I do see force in the point that
his own conduct is a matter of legitimate
public reporting." Before the election the then shadow
chancellor, Gordon Brown,
criticised tax avoidance loopholes
generally. At the Labour party conference
in 1994 he branded those who use such
schemes as the "some thing for nothing
elite" and the "undeserving rich". Labour
went on to pledge that it would "take
action against the tax abuses and
avoidance on the part of a few which
result in higher demands on the
overwhelming majority". It said it was "indefensible that a
very wealthy few are allowed to work or
live in the UK without making a fair
contribution through taxation". Levy is known to have used offshore
trusts in the past and his companies had
links with one or more tax havens until
1997. But at around the time of the
general election he moved the Michael Levy
Acquisitions Trust, an offshore trust
based in Guernsey, back to the UK. It was also reported that a second
offshore trust - The Rothschild Trust in
Guernsey, which held the shares of his
principal company, Wireart - was altered
at about the same time, with Levy and his
wife, Gilda, taking over as
trustees. With his acute business sense, Levy is
best known within Labour as the mastermind
behind the party's high-value donation
unit. Before the election he was assigned
responsibility for the "blind trust" that
funded Blair's private office, and secured
donations from dozens of leading
businessmen, including Lord
Puttnam, the film producer. The life-long Labour supporter also
secured a £1m donation from
Ecclestone, which the party was famously
forced to repay when it was revealed in
November 1997 that Labour had been pushing
the EU for an extension to tobacco
advertising in Formula One. Levy, who is domiciled in the United
Kingdom for tax purposes, was born in
Hackney, East London. He and his wife live
in a multi-million-pound mansion in Mill
Hill, north London, and count Blair among
their dinner guests. He is also patron or
chairman of numerous charities. Levy and
Blair, former tennis partners, first met
in 1994 at a dinner party, where they were
introduced by a senior Israeli
diplomat. Last night Levy issued a statement
explaining why he had paid only
£5,000 in tax for 1998/99: "I devoted
that period to political and voluntary
activities, none of which provided any
income for me. I was living off my own
savings on which all tax owing had been
paid." He denied he employed a highly
sophisticated tax avoidance strategy
involving offshore holdings: "There is no
such strategy and there are no such
holdings." Levy claims he sought the injunction
because this newspaper had obtained his
tax details "unlawfully". In fact, he
sought the injunction on grounds of breach
of confidence and the tax information was
presented to the paper by a third
party. Insight: Paul Nuki, Gareth Walsh,
David Leppard and Humfrey Hunter |