AN ISRAELI historian has made a thought-provoking contribution to the Internet discussion on the death-roll fin the Holocaust...

Quick navigationsearch  
H-Net
[H-Net Humanities & Social Sciences OnLine]

Re: number of survivors?

Friday, January 15, 1999

Reply-To: H-NET List for History of the Holocaust <[email protected]>
Sender: H-NET List for History of the Holocaust <
[email protected]

From: John Lemberger <[email protected]>

Friends,

Ester Golan's question has been answered but will continue to resonate until we can be certain of the answer. In 1948 there were 600,000 Jews living in Palestine (pre-State). Within a short period of time, 10-15 years, two mass migrations tripled Israel's population: One was approximately 600,000 from North Africa and Arab countries, and the other, with a similar number, 600,000, from the remnants of the Shoa in Europe.

At the time, the estimate was that Israel absorbed two-thirds of the survivors. Today according to different estimates, with serious issues of "who is a survivor" the worldwide figures stand at between 600-900,000. In Israel, there are 360,000 survivors with about two-thirds over 65, and one-third having been children during the war.

These Israeli figures are based on a paper of the Brookdale Institute (to be found in our book, "A Global Perspective on Working With Holocaust Survivors and the Second Generation," John Lemberger, ed., published 1995 by JDC-Israel, Brookdale and AMCHA). We hope, shortly, to have updated Israeli figures based on the Israeli census of people 60+ carried out a few years ago. The Israeli numbers I cited include approximately 60,000 survivors from the Former Soviet Union who have recently emigrated to Israel.

John Lemberger
AMCHA http://www.amcha.org

IrvingTHIS IS precisely the kind of firm statistical basis needed to extrapolate backwards to 1945 to establish a realistic figure of Holocaust survivors. If two-thirds of those in Israel today, estimated at 360,000, are over sixty-five years old, an actuary could work backwards and arrive at an excellent figure.

Any actuaries out there please? We shall post their input on this Website, if received.

© Focal Point 1999 F e-mail: DISmall write to David Irving