Sunday,
November 30, 2008 TV
documentary allows David Irving to speak
freely On
December 9, 2008: British TV Channel 4 will show
the ninety-minute Rex Bloomstein film, An
Independent Mind The
film was premiered on September 14, 2008 at the
Curzon Cinema, Soho The
English Centre of International PEN reviewed the
film approvingly: THE final interview, and arguably the most
controversial, was with the historian David
Irving. While he still vehemently denies
accusations of racism, anti-Semitism and Holocaust
denial, Irving conceded that he had voiced "doubts
and scepticism" about Auschwitz
during a speech he had given in Austria
in 1989. He
was arrested for attempting to reactivate the Nazi
party and in trial admitted that he had denied that
Nazi Germany had killed millions of Jews. In
February 2006, he was sentenced to three years in
prison. While in no way condoning Irving's position on
the Holocaust, English PEN deplored the court's
decision. "It should not be a crime in a free
society to publish opinion, however poorly dressed
up as fact," PEN said in a statement. "It is more
important than ever that democracies deal with
contentious issues through debate and ridicule
rather than through suppression by law." Similarly, Irving contended that everyone should
be given a voice, no matter how contentious their
opinion. "I want to visit a free Germany where
everyone is free to say what they want and that
every opinion can be freely held up and exposed
either to acclaim or ridicule," he said. "As soon
as you start saying this opinion is acceptable and
that option isn't acceptable then you are degrading
society, and society is losing in the long run."
While Bloomstein conceded that Irving "represents
something immensely troubling" he was adamant that
"we have to take these people on [
]
Irving makes us think about the limits." Royal
Society of Arts on 8 December 2008 at 6.30pm.
An audience Q&A with BAFTA award-winning
director, Rex Bloomstein, chaired by
Jonathan Miller, Foreign Affairs
Correspondent, Channel 4 News, will follow.
Coinciding with the 60th anniversary of the
universal declaration of human rights, this
unique film gives a voice to eight characters
from around the world who have fought to
exercise their right to free speech. Their
stories include facing the threat of
imprisonment for drawing a cartoon, being
tortured for writing a poem and being forced
into exile for singing a song. This bold and
provocative film exposes that it is not just the
developing world but also in Western democracies
that abuses of freedom of expression are taking
place. If you are interested in attending, please
email more4events@channel4.co.uk
or contact Jennifer Chorley on 0207 306
5640. See also: Charlie
Beckett on An Independent Mind.
On October 1, 2008 Mr Irving wrote to film producer
Rex Bloomstein: "Dear Rex, -- I watched the
film three times on Sunday with friends, and we
were all deeply impressed. Not only was the quality
so good, but the lighting and background selection
[the Library at Chatham House] were
brilliant, and the topic was interestingly conveyed
and researched. Even I was taken aback by the
quality of my arguments! You really put me at my
ease." |