The
Independent 11 November 2003 Revealed:
the fascist past of
the
[London]
Daily
Mirror AS
the Daily Mirror marks its 100th
birthday, there is one part of the
paper's history it is not celebrating.
Chris Horrie unmasks an unlikely
love affair with Oswald Mosley IT IS one of the
choicest pieces of journalistic dinner
party general knowledge that the filthy
right-wing Daily Mail was
officially a fascist newspaper in the
1930s. The paper was burned on the streets
after running the headline "Hurrah for the
Blackshirts" and backing Oswald
Mosley's plan to make himself
Britain's equivalent of Adolf
Hitler. No surprise then, so the
conversational gambit goes, that the
Mail is still beating up on asylum
seekers today. What is less well known is that the
Mail's former stablemate the Daily
Mirror was just as pro-fascist. On
Monday, 22 January, 1934 the Mirror ran
the headline "Give the Blackshirts a
helping hand". The paper went one further
than the Mail, urging readers to join
Mosley's British Union of Fascists, and
giving the address to which to send
membership applications. "As a purely British organisation, the
Blackshirts will respect those principles
of tolerance which are traditional in
British politics," the Mirror told
readers, complaining that "timid
alarmists" had "been whimpering that the
rapid growth in numbers of the British
Blackshirts is preparing the way for a
system of rulership by means of steel
whips and concentration camps". This was nonsense, the Mirror
said, the result of ignorance of the
reality of "Blackshirt government" in
Hitler's Germany: "The notion that a
permanent reign of terror exists there has
been evolved entirely from their own
morbid imaginations, fed by sensational
propaganda from opponents of the party now
in power." The paper added that anyone who had
visited Germany or Mussolini's Italy
"would find that the mood of the vast
majority of their inhabitants was not
cowed submission but confident
enthusiasm." The Mirror's Sunday sister
paper, then known as The Pictorial,
followed up with a Hello!-style picture
essay showing uniformed blackshirt
paramilitaries playing table tennis and
enjoying a sing-song around the piano
while off duty inside the Black House,
Mosley's barracks-cum-dungeon on London's
King's Road. The Mirror and the
Pictorial also planned a
photographic beauty contest aimed at
finding Britain's prettiest woman fascist
-- though Mosley personally objected to
this, saying the paper was trivialising
his movement. The author of the Mirror's
"helping hand" article was Harold
Harmsworth, the first Lord
Rothermere, great grandfather of the
current Daily Mail proprietor.
Rothermere had inherited both papers from
his older brother Lord Northcliffe,
but had slowly sold off shares in the
Mirror, enabling him to invest in
the more profitable Mail.
Surprisingly, perhaps, when the
Mirror piece was published, he no
longer owned the paper. But he still held
considerable sway over the paper's board
of directors, which he had appointed,
including editorial director Harry Guy
"Bart" Bartholomew - the man credited
with creating the modern tabloid
Mirror - and Rothermere's nephew
Cecil King, who was to run the
paper in its glory years of the 1950s and
1960s. The change of
ownership did not at first change the
paper's pro-fascist editorial stance.
And when the change came it had more to
do with money than ideology.
Rothermere's right-wing propaganda had
badly hit the paper's sales.
Bartholomew and King's solution was to
re-launch the paper as a New York-style
tabloid aimed at a working-class
audience. "Our best hope," King later wrote in
his memoirs, "was to appeal to young,
working-class men and women... If this was
the aim, the politics had to be made to
match. In the depression of the thirties,
there was no future in preaching
right-wing politics to young people who
were in the lowest income bracket." When the political shift in the
Mirror came it was cautious. The
paper backed the Conservative leader
Stanley Baldwin in the 1935
election, and then gradually adopted an
anti-appeasement policy. But politics was
far less important in the re-launched,
tabloid Mirror. The paper cut its
politics coverage by half and vastly
increased its sport reporting,
shock-horror pictures, lurid crime tales,
cartoons, human-interest material and
pin-up pictures. King and Bartholomew's American-style
tabloid formula - put into action with
enormous panache by legendary Welsh
tabloid feature-writer Hugh Cudlipp
- doubled the circulation to 1.5 million
by 1939. During the war - in true tabloid style
- the Mirror became super-patriotic, and
won for itself the reputation of being
"the soldiers' paper". Much of the paper's
radical reputation rested on its demagogic
attacks on the "Colonel Blimp"
Conservative politicians and upper-class
army officers who made such a mess of the
war effort in its early stages. But the idea of the 1930s Mirror as a
great champion of the anti-Nazi cause is
largely mythical. And there is no
indication that Cecil King ever changed
his politics. King remained an admirer of
Oswald Mosley, announcing in his memoirs
that Mosley had been "the outstanding
politician of his generation" and that his
only mistake was to have "chosen the wrong
side during the war". After the war, Cecil King came to run
the Mirror with as much autocratic power
as any proprietor. But wisely, he left the
contents of the paper to Cudlipp, the man
with the common touch. Despite the paper's
reputation for supporting all things
socially radical in the 1950s and 1960s,
its editorial support for Labour was
lukewarm. King still felt the
Harmsworth-Rothermere blood coursing
through his veins and loathed Labour's
post-war leaders Attlee ("a
complete drip") and Gaitskell ("a
vain man without substance or principle").
He warmed at first to Harold
Wilson, mainly because Wilson had
promised to take the UK into the European
Common Market. By the 1960s
the theme of a "united Europe" standing
between what the Mosleyites saw as a
Mongolian-Asiatic Russia and a
Jewish-Negro America had become an
obsession with the exiled Mosley and
also with King. Dumbfounded hacks at
the Mirror were required to
write article after article setting out
the plan for "Nation Europa", which
were then foisted on a mostly baffled
Mirror readership. In 1968, after Wilson dragged his feet
on Europe, and at the height of a run on
the pound, King commandeered the front
page of the Mirror to demand
Wilson's removal from office. At the same
time, amid talk of a military coup, King
held a meeting with Mosley at his mansion
outside Paris, sounding him out as a
possible member of a "government of
national unity". Peter Stephens, the
Mirror's Paris correspondent sent a
report back to Cudlipp in London (now
contained in Cudlipp's private archive at
Cardiff University) reporting that King
had said that Mosley was still "an
extremely brilliant man" who could "still
make a useful contribution" to the running
of the country. Stephens, astonished, had
asked: "You are surely not thinking of
including him in your replacement
government?" King had replied: "Why not?
People have forgotten about his past." In the event - after some further
meetings with military officers and an
audience with the potential figurehead
Lord Mountbatten - King's plan for
the establishment of a Mirror-led
military dictatorship fizzled out and was
written off as an act of insanity. King's role in the 1968 "coup that
never was" is still controversial. But the
fact remains that for much of the Mirror's
admittedly brilliant 100-year reign as the
self-proclaimed "Newspaper of the
Century", it had a dark side which many
now prefer discreetly to forget. Chris Horrie is author of 'Tabloid
Nation: From the birth of the Mirror to
the death of the tabloid newspaper'; Andre
Deutsch, £17.99
|