Documents on Real History

Letters to David Irving on this Website


Unless correspondents ask us not to, this Website will post selected letters that it receives and invite open debate.

Quick navigation

 

Website readers answer the question debated in a public lecture by Prof. Hyam Maccoby, answering David Irving's fundamental Holocaust question: "Why are the Jews not Liked?" (Anthony Stadlen reported)


typewriter

 

Why are Jews Disliked? Some possible answers (#1)

John Parsons comments on Monday, December 11, 2000:

It's interesting what Professor Maccoby failed to say. The mass media in America are almost totally controlled by Jews which is obvious for all to see: there is an agenda which promotes protection of minorities - like the Jews - at the expense of the majority.

A religion, the Holocaust, has been set up which forbids any discussion of what happened to the Jews in Europe in WWII and has ensured hundreds of billions of dollars being funnelled to Israel as guilt money.

Its antithesis, holocaust denial, is a heresy in Germany and France where people go to jail who question any aspect of the gas chamber story on the grounds that they are stirring up "hate".

 

The controlled media also fail to show the appalling treatment of the Palestinian people under a brutal, nazi-like regime.

The banking system is largely controlled by Jewish elites: the Federal Reserve participatory banks are almost all Jewish-run.

Why are the Jews hated ? They have enormous power which they misuse for their own partisan adavantage. If you want to listen to Maccoby tell nice stories about Jews in India and China, that's all very well: but he didn't answer the elephant-in-the-dining-room question . . .

John Parsons


David Irving responds:

I personally do not object to Jews controlling Hollywood, banks, newspapers and the rest, provided that (a) they do a better job than those they are displacing, and (b) they do not use their position to disadvantage non-Jews. Ah, but there's the rub.


Joe Assi also comments:

HOW does Maccoby treat the fact that the ancient Egyptians, Greeks and Romans (amongst others in antiquity) hated the Jews with more ferocity than anyone else in history? This fact seems to overwhelmingly destroy Maccoby's thesis.

© Focal Point 2000 David Irving