Posted Friday, October 18, 2002

Quick navigation

Click for non-JavaScript index | Index to the Traditional Enemies of Free Speech

The Nazi War on Cancer

by Robert Proctor

380 pages (19 avril 1999)
Princeton University Press; ISBN : 0691001960



FAMILIAR as we are with the horrific history of Nazi medicine and science, it may come as a surprise to learn that the Nazi war against cancer was the most aggressive in the world. Robert N. Proctor's thought-provoking book, The Nazi War on Cancer recounts this little-known story. The Nazis were very concerned about protecting the health of the "Volk."

David Irving comments:

WHAT'S THAT? The Nazis were fighting cancer more than the axis of Goodness?

Cancer was seen as a growing threat -- and perhaps even held a special place in Adolf Hitler's imagination (his mother, Klara, died from breast cancer in 1907). The Nazi doctors fought their war against cancer on many fronts, battling environmental and workplace hazards (restrictions on the use of asbestos) and recommending food standards (bans on carcinogenic pesticides and food dyes) and early detection ("men were advised to get their colons checked as often as they would check the engines of their cars...").

Armed with the world's most sophisticated tobacco-disease epidemiology -- they were the first to link smoking to lung cancer definitively -- Nazi doctors were especially passionate about the hazards of tobacco. Hitler himself was a devout nonsmoker, and credited his political success to kicking the habit. Proctor does an excellent job of charting these anticancer efforts -- part of what he terms "the 'flip side' of fascism" -- and, along the way, touches on some unsettling issues.

Can an immoral regime promote and produce morally responsible science? Or, in Proctor's words, "Do we look at history differently when we learn that . . . Nazi health officials worried about asbestos-induced lung cancer? I think we do. We learn that Nazism was a more subtle phenomenon than we commonly imagine, more seductive, more plausible."


Proctor is no apologist -- one of his earlier books, Racial Hygiene is a scathing account of Nazi atrocities -- but he clearly wants to engage in the complex moral discussions surrounding the fascist production of science and Holocaust studies. Proctor's thorough research, excellent examples, and dozens of illustrations are complemented by his authoritative prose. The Nazi War on Cancer is a fine addition to the literature on both the Holocaust and the history of medicine. -- C.B. Delaney


"[A] fascinating book . . . . Proctor's account is outstanding . . . A generation ago, Hannah Arendt increased the world's understanding of Nazi behavior (and caused a lot of controversy) by talking about the 'banality of evil.' Robert N. Proctor has now brought us a concept nearly as unsettling, the 'banality of good.'" -- David Brown, Washington Post Book World


on this website:

  Hitler's doctors' war on cancer. Book review | Dr John Fox writes about Hitler's other War
  Nazi scientists were first to Nail Tobacco as Cause of Lung Cancer
  Help to fund
The above news item is reproduced without editing other than typographical
 Register your name and address to go on the Mailing List to receive

David Irving's ACTION REPORT

© Focal Point 2002 F Irving write to David Irving